Staff - Help - Contact Search:
buy this title





Sisu






Thelma & Louise






Scream 6






Avatar






The Covenant






The Truman Show




Frankenstein

Comparison:

  • Theatrical Cut
  • Reborn Cut
Release: Nov 15, 2026 - Author: Muck47 - Translator: Muck47 - external link: IMDB

Comparison between the theatrical version and the Reborn Cut (both included in the Criterion Collection’s 4K UHD/Blu-ray set)

 

- 32 differences, including 4 bits with alternative material and 7 additional scenes in the theatrical version
- Difference: 514 sec (= 8:34 min)

 

With Frankenstein (2025), director Guillermo del Toro brought one of his absolute dream projects to life. He had already been greenlit by Universal Pictures back in 2008, but the studio had other plans over time, and it took another 15 years before Netflix announced that del Toro would now be directing the film for the streaming service. In addition to select theatrical releases, the film thus became available on the platform’s in-house VOD service as early as November 2025, and at the 2026 Academy Awards, its nine nominations resulted in three actual wins (Best Production Design, Best Makeup and Hairstyling, and Best Costume Design).

The cult label The Criterion Collection, which releases films in the U.S. and the U.K., had already released a new extended Director’s Cut in black-and-white (report) of del Toro’s Nightmare Alley for the first time as part of the 4K premiere in 2025. As of October 27, 2026, a 4K UHD/Blu-ray combo set of Frankenstein is now available simultaneously in the U.S. and the U.K., and once again, it exclusively includes a longer cut.

 

Differences in the “Reborn Cut” of FRANKENSTEIN (2025)

As the name “Reborn Cut” suggests, this is likely best understood as an alternative version, and the director is also satisfied with the theatrical version. A very significant aspect is a key scene, regarding which del Toro explained in the audio commentary that James Cameron had recommended he remove it for general release. This is a scene where we actually see young Victor Frankenstein kill his father. In doing so, he has effectively already avenged his mother, which raises the question whether his continued quest for immortality remains plausible. Furthermore, Victor is clearly intended as a likable character with whom the audience can identify, and this act may make it harder for some viewers to relate to him.

Beyond that, several additional scenes featuring Elizabeth (Mia Goth) stand out in particular. The most striking is probably the moment when she kneels in a church and then greets her fiancé William (Felix Kammerer). But the direct relationship with Victor and how this fits in with his brother William is also better explored here in several moments. Anyone hoping for more screen time with Mia Goth will certainly get their money’s worth here, not least thanks to a spectacular mini-addition in which, as a jump-scare-inducing dream sequence, maggots are seen crawling out of the face of Victor’s dead mother (also portrayed by Goth).

Otherwise, there are several small scene segments or editing changes in the theatrical version. Christoph Waltz, as Henrich Harlander, also gets to add a few extra lines of dialogue. All in all, however, these are less striking than the differences just mentioned. The Reborn Cut is an exciting addition to the theatrical version and emphasizes different aspects of the story, but anyone who didn’t warm up to the theatrical version will certainly not have a completely different experience with this version either.

 

Runtime information is organized according to the following format
The theatrical version at 23.976 fps / Reborn Cut at 23.976 fps

A slightly longer black screen at the beginning of the theatrical version.

+ 0.8 sec



08:26 / 08:25–08:35

After the opening sequence, the next scene begins a little earlier.

Captain: “What the devil was that? Our men-- have you treated them?”
Doctor: “Those who survived, yes. The stump has healed; the scar has even hardened.”

9.4 sec




08:28 / 08:37–08:56

A brief side shot is also included in the theatrical version, after which further dialogue is missing.

Captain: “War?”
Doctor: “Whatever war this man fought, he lost. Fluid in his lungs, cyanotic spots on his back. His right hand is crushed. He doesn’t have long. I’ll do my best, but eventually—”
Victor lets out a sound; “What are you doing?”
Captain: “English? Do you understand English?”

19.6 sec




09:46 / 10:14–10:23

The camera zooms in on the ship for a longer time, and during this, Victor’s commentary can already be heard, which continues into the subsequent scene that begins earlier: “So enormous are my crimes. Yet, I must make you understand, it was the only way.”

8.3 sec




12:59 / 13:36–14:13

Victor lies down in bed next to his mother, Claire, and says: “After my brother is born…”
Claire: “William… Guillaume. My darling.”
Victor: “After William is born… Will you love me just as always?”
Claire: “Even more, if that’s possible.”
Victor lies down on her stomach and listens; “I think I hear his heartbeat.”

37.6 sec




17:37 / 18:51–18:55

The tracking shot of Victor closing his eyes is briefly interrupted only in the Reborn Cut by a nightmarish shot of Claire’s corpse. Maggots are crawling out of every orifice.

4.2 sec




19:51 / 21:09–21:17

Victor takes longer to get out of bed and looks at himself in the mirror.

As a result, his voice-over commentary was shifted slightly. Even in the identical shots earlier, he says the following, which differs slightly: “(And it made me a promise.) I was to protect myself and William from the whims of the beast. And in exchange, (I would have command over the forces of life and death.)”

Following these additional shots, the subsequent commentary familiar from the theatrical version (enclosed in parentheses) is then heard.

8 sec



After two identical sentences, the voice-over comments diverge.

Theatrical version: “The vision was so clear. Clearer than anything I’d ever seen in my waking hours or dreams”
Reborn Cut: “Guardian angel. Sweet companion. But before any of that could come to be...”

Alternative / Additional material in the theatrical version
20:05–20:10 / 21:31–21:34

The scene, or rather, the monologue, takes a completely different turn.

In the theatrical version, the statue is shown for a little longer, and Victor raises his arms. Additionally, the adult Victor concludes the voice-over with: “But how?”


In the Reborn Cut, the scene cuts back to adult Victor, who concludes: “I had to kill him.”


The theatrical version is 2 seconds longer


Alternative
20:33–20:44 / 21:57–24:40

After the scene on the ice, the theatrical version shows Victor again, who says, “My downfall was swift. Two revolts and a fire on my mother’s plantations dwindled the family fortune. We kept the estate, but lost everything else.”


In the Reborn Cut, the most memorable change now follows: We see young Victor poison his father, Baron Leopold.

The Captain asks, “Did you?”
Victor now says on screen what was previously heard in a voiceover in the theatrical version: “The vision was so clear. Clearer than anything I’d ever seen in my waking hours or dreams. But how?”
A flashback begins in which the young Victor walks through the library; “How could I extinguish this detestable beast in a single, elegant stroke? And then she came to me. To my assistance. The quiet death. La Madonna Tenebrosa. I found her in an old Italian volume about poisons. The unlikely combination of root extracts, potassium, and alpine black lichen—a modest, almost resentful little plant that grew in the shade of granite.”
We see him outside, gathering the ingredients, then the adult Victor continues: “To say where I harvested this ruthless remedy would be… poetic. Perhaps even boastful. But I harvested it all the same. And with it, my father’s fate was sealed.”
Back in the flashback, we see Victor walking away from his mother’s grave and then carefully dripping the mixture into his sleeping father’s ear.
The next day, Leopold is sitting at the table eating, and when he sets down his glass, you see a small spatter of blood.
In a dry tone, he says, “Theo, get me my medical bag,” stares intently at the frightened Victor, and then collapses.


Reborn Cut 152.3 sec (= 2:32 min) longer


26:33 / 30:30–30:48

It starts a little earlier inside, and Henrich admires Victor’s work.

Victor: “No need to close the door.”
Henrich: “You did these?”
Victor: “The wax models are just road maps. A way to organize my thoughts.”
Henrich: “You’re an artist.”
Victor: “Many would disagree.”

18.5 sec




28:31 / 32:46–33:54

In an additional scene, Elizabeth kneels before a crucifix in the convent. She approaches the figure, lifts her veil, and briefly touches her stomach.
Another nun says in a voice-over: “Sister Elizabeth? Your fiancé awaits.”
Her fiancé William is now standing there, and they embrace.

68 sec (= 1:08 min)




37:15 / 42:38

A scene on the ship begins slightly earlier, and already from this point on, the voice-over dialogue differs.

0.4 sec



37:19 / 42:42–42:51

Captain Anderson addresses his men in somewhat more detail: “No one comes near him, is that understood? Those of you who are afraid can form a perimeter around the ship.”

8.3 sec




42:47 / 48:19–49:18

In a completely additional scene, Victor talks with Elizabeth about her relationship with William, and there’s a bit of flirting.

Victor: “How soon?”
Elizabeth: “I saw you well before you saw me—I can say that much.”
Victor: “Impressive.”
Elizabeth: “It is a woman’s nature to remain alert.”
Victor: “I would never doubt your gifts.”
Elizabeth: “It’s not a gift. It’s a fear.”
Victor: “Of William?”
Elizabeth: “Yes. As you know, he’s traveling through the war zone at the moment, and I pray—”
Victor: “And you pray for his well-being?”
Elizabeth: “I do. He is kind, gentle, and full of life.”
Victor: “I daresay you two make a curious match. I’m glad you care for him so much.”
Elizabeth: “As do you, I imagine?”
Victor: “Oh, yes, I’ve cared for William, in one way or another, since he was just a little runt. Sometimes to my own detriment, you see. “
Elizabeth: ”He’s grateful for it, I’m sure.“
Victor: ”I’m sure. Have you had supper?“
Elizabeth: ”I’m not that hungry, Baron, and it’s—“
Victor: ”Oh!“
Elizabeth: ”It’s late.“
Victor: ”I, for one, am famished. After all, I’ve just come from a hanging."

58.9 sec




Alternative
43:52–43:55 / 50:22–50:34

In the Reborn Cut, Elizabeth says: “Every woman within those walls is there not for vacation, but by circumstance.
Victor: “How so?”
Elizabeth: “Lack of a dowry. Lack of beauty. The convent offered me silence and a vast library to continue my education.”

In the theatrical version, however, a different shot of Elizabeth is shown as she comments, “In a way”, this was already moved in the Reborn Cut to follow Victor’s previous line.

Reborn Cut is 9.2 seconds longer

Theatrical VersionReborn Cut




45:15 / 51:55–51:57

At the beginning of a shot, Victor says: “Pure silver is a perfect conductor.”

1.8 sec




Additional material in the theatrical version
45:20 / 52:01

In the theatrical version, this same line was somewhat oddly layered over the slightly longer transition to the next scene.

+ 0.4 sec




45:26 / 52:07–52:15

The line “Only for a few more days” was cut; instead, there is some additional dialogue.

Victor: “Mr. Harlander.”
Henrich: “Will you stay behind?”
William nods; “Very well, Mr. Harlander.”

7.6 sec




46:18 / 53:07-53:16

Elizabeth starts playing the piano earlier, and the camera pans up to her. The follow-up shot of Victor behind the table also begins a little earlier.

8.8 sec




Additional material in the theatrical version
47:00–47:02 / 53:58

For whatever reason, Elizabeth appears a bit earlier here in the theatrical version.

+ 1.8 sec




49:30 / 56:26–56:35

Victor says: “(An almost physical one.) Or are my attentions unwelcome? Unwanted? Say so, and I shall withdraw them. Every gaze, I will avert. Every heartbeat, I will suffocate. (But I truly believe it to be something else.)”

9 sec




84:03 / 91:08–91:22

Victor adds: “(For her own safety.) Then go get help. I’ll be here. I’ll be waiting.”
William: “Will you be safe?”
Victor: “I will. But you must do as I say.”
He strokes William’s shoulders.

13.8 sec




Additional material in the theatrical version
100:40 / 107:58

The dog-and-wolf bite scene is a fraction of a second longer in the theatrical version.

+ 0.6 sec




Additional material in the theatrical version
101:42–101:43 / 109:00

In the theatrical version, the animal runs out of the frame for a negligible amount of time longer.

+ 0.3 sec


About two minutes later, there’s another trivial difference of less than 0.5 sec, but it really isn’t worth listing in more detail.



106:26 / 113:44–113:59

Another brief scene with the blind grandfather and the creature. The grandfather hands over another book, and as the creature takes it, it bumps its head. The two of them smile.

14.9 sec




117:29 / 125:02–125:06

Interestingly, only the Reborn Cut here includes a subdivision into a third part (“Fathers and Sons”), whereas Part 2 was identical in both versions.

4.3 sec




118:50 / 126:27–126:44

More dialogue between Victor and William.

William: “There’s no life here. No future. And I, too, need a life of my own. And Elizabeth will give me that.”
Victor: “Mm-hmm.”
William: “Without Harlander... (all we have is each other.)"

17.2 sec




118:59 / 126:53–127:19

The scene is also significantly longer at the end, and Victor even flatters William.

William: “I’ll share the profits with you, and we’ll both be free of this… edifice of sorrow.”
Victor: “You, indeed, are the kindest man I have ever known. And I love you.”

25.6 sec




Alternative / Additional material in the theatrical version
129:15–129:16 / 137:35–137:40

While in the theatrical cut the shot where the creature grabs Victor is just a little longer...


...the Reborn Cut shows the creature again, and Victor says: “Do it! Kill me! Kill me now! Do it!”


Reborn Cut is 4.6 sec longer


129:27 / 137:51–137:54

At the beginning of the follow-up shot, the creature also says: “Your pretty, pretty face.”

2.3 sec




129:31 / 137:58–138:04

The creature sticks its finger in Victor’s mouth; “I will silence your mouth full of lies.”

6.4 sec




Additional material in the theatrical version
129:34–129:36 / 138:07

Only in the theatrical version does Victor say here (and, in part, in the identical moment just before this), as he did a few scenes earlier in the Reborn Cut: “Kill me! Kill me now, do it!”

+ 2 sec




137:39 / 146:10–146:12

At the end of the shot, Victor repeats the striking word once more: “Live.”

2.3 sec