Staff - Help - Contact Search:
other comparisons




Caltiki The Immortal Monster






Heat






Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them






Hellraiser: The Scarlet Box Limited Edition Tril




Oliver Twist (2005) - Likely cut internationally

Censored for UK cinema, worldwide identical

Roman Polanski's film adaptation of Charles Dickens' novel was a European co-production and released in 2005.

As the entry in the BBFC database shows, the film had problems during the rating process for the cinematical run in the UK. One scene was too much for the desired "PG" rating. The distributor chose to censor it.

Before the formal submission of the film, the company was given advice that the strength of the beating delivered by Bill Sykes (Jamie Foreman) to Nancy (Leanne Rowe) was unlikely to be acceptable at the PG category. The footage was reduced in strength in the version submitted for classification.

 Said scene can be found approx. 100 mins into the film. In the UK version, Bill hits five times. We see him taking a swipe three times and while the other two attacks are carried out, we only see the dog sitting next to the action. The runtime of the theatrical version with this censorship notice is completely identical (after conversion) to the runtime of the version that's been put out on DVD.

It has happened numerous times that such mainstream productions have been censored for a younger public in the UK while other European countries or even the rest of the world got the uncensored version (or a differently censored one, just think about the chaos with James Bond 007: Casino Royale).

This was reason enough for us to check several other releases to see what's the situation there. We checked:

- British DVD (PG) by Pathe!

- German DVD (FSK 12) by Tobis/UFA

- American DVD (PG-13) by Sony/TriStar

- French DVD (Tous Publics) by Pathe!

Unfortunately, we could only come to the sobering conclusion that all versions were completely identical, be it in the particular scene as well as in total. Small runtime differences are due to alternative production logos/credits in the beginning.


Even though the checked DVDs do not necessarily represent all worldwide releases, this selection should give an orientation regarding the worldwide status. It can be assumed that the film was released in a censored version internationally.

Release: Jul 03, 2012 - Author: Muck47 - Translator: Mike Lowrey - Source: BBFC-Prüfeintrag

The Latest News

Jun 22, 2017 The Bird with the Crystal Plumage by Arrow Video (4K Remasted Blu-ray in June)

Jun 22, 2017 Madhouse on Blu-ray (Arrow Video Release in the UK and US)

Jun 22, 2017 The Stendhal Syndrome by Blue Underground (2K Remastered US Blu-ray in July)

Jun 22, 2017 The Lawnmower Man with Both Versions on Blu-ray (Theatrical Version and Director's Cut in the US)

Jun 17, 2017 Transformers: The Last Knight with a Longer Cut? (Allegedly Longer in China But Length Is Puzzling)

Jun 17, 2017 Sony Starts Clean Version Initiative (Authors Can't Wait to Get Their Hands on Those)

Jun 17, 2017 Spider-Man 3 - Editor's Cut Released on Blu-ray (US Gets New Cut in Limited Edition)

Jun 09, 2017 Just Before Dawn on Blu-ray in the UK (80's Slasher to Be Released by 88 Films)

Jun 09, 2017 Event Horizon - No Extended Cut After All (Paul W. S. Anderson Claims the Footage Was Gone)

Jun 09, 2017 Hellboy - Reboot About to Come (Reboot Supposed to Be Rated R)

comments powered by Disqus




Terms of Use - Contact - ADMIN